Sunday, November 21, 2021

BROWNSTONE INSTITUTE: Organization Condemns the Political Attempt to Stigmatize Personal Medical Choice

Source: Brownstone Institute

Published: October 29, 2021

By: Günter Kampf

This Is Not a Pandemic of the Unvaccinated

Some politicians speak about the “pandemic of the unvaccinated.” But fully vaccinated individuals can harbour high viral loads, spread SARS-CoV-2 and cause severe and fatal Covid-19, also among other fully vaccinated individuals. Social cohesion should not be jeopardized because of an erroneous and narrow view of the epidemiological situation.

At the beginning of the pandemic, large numbers of Covid-19 patients in China (79.8%) felt discriminated against. They were seen as a threat to others. Once the vaccination became available, they were less frequently seen as a threat presumably because the vaccinated felt safe (1).

Currently, however, unvaccinated people are increasingly being blamed for the pandemic. In July 2021, U.S. President Joseph Biden made the following comments: “Look, the only pandemic we have is among the unvaccinated“ (2). Germany’s health minister Jens Spahn said in August 2021 that they are currently seeing a “pandemic of the unvaccinated.” Between 90% and 95% of Covid-19 patients in intensive care units are unvaccinated, he said (3). 

The Austrian chancellor Sebastian Kurz used the same wording in September 2021 (4). Even the German TV channel ZDF used this wording as a news headline. After high-ranking politicians released this choice of words for use in public, individual scientists followed suit a short time later. 

Goldman recently blamed the unvaccinated to serve as a pool for variants and that the unvaccinated threaten the vaccinated. Only one part of the population is seen by him as a threat when he describes the unvaccinated as a “breeding ground for the virus to continue to generate variants” and speculates that “lockdowns and masks will once again be required” and that “many more who are currently protected, especially among the vulnerable, will die” because some people do not get vaccinated (5). 

These are serious accusations from a scientist against a part of society. But are they justified?

What is a pandemic?

The International Epidemiology Association’s Dictionary of Epidemiology defines a pandemic as “an epidemic occurring worldwide, or over a very wide area, crossing international boundaries and usually affecting a large number of people (6). The definition has never been restricted to a specific part of the population like the unvaccinated, the elderly or the obese. The term “pandemic of the unvaccinated” is therefore not an epidemiological or scientific term but rather a political one.

The increasing stigmatization of “the unvaccinated”

Unvaccinated citizens in Germany experience increasing stigmatization and separation from the rest of society. In a number of federal states, the legal basis has been established allowing restaurants to exclude unvaccinated people to eat inside even if tested negative for Covid-19. Attending cultural events organized by the local authorities is not allowed in some cities in Germany. In these settings, vaccinated and recovered citizens, however, do not need to keep physical distance from others and do not need to wear a mask. 

Decisionmakers assume that they cannot really be a source of transmission. In the federal states of Lower Saxony and Hessen the governments now even allow supermarkets to deny shopping to the unvaccinated with a negative test result.

Vaccination offers only partial protection

The phase 3 trials of Covid-19 vaccines clearly show that vaccination results only in a partial protection for Covid-19, not in a full protection (7-10). More and more reports are published providing epidemiological evidence for only partial protection of the vaccinated. In Massachusetts, a total of 469 new Covid-19 cases was detected during various events in July 2021, of which 346 cases occurred in those who were fully or incompletely vaccinated (74%). 274 of these affected individuals were symptomatic (79%). Ct values were comparably low in all groups (median: 21.5 to 22.8), indicating a high viral load, even among the fully vaccinated (11). 

The largest evaluation of breakthrough infections to date comes from the United States. There, a total of 10,262 Covid-19 cases were reported in vaccinated individuals by April 30, 2021, of which 27% were asymptomatic, 10% were hospitalized, and 2% died (12). In Germany, the rate of symptomatic Covid-19 among the fully vaccinated (“breakthrough infections”) is reported weekly since July 21, 2021, and was 16.9% at that time among patients of 60 years and older (13). 

This proportion is increasing week by week and was 57.0% on 20. October 2021, providing clear evidence of the increasing relevance of the fully vaccinated as a possible source of transmission. Similar findings on the number of Covid-19 cases among the fully vaccinated were reported from the UK (14).

Another example is a professional soccer team in Germany where 12 new cases were recently detected. Some players showed relevant symptoms of Covid-19. Ten players were vaccinated, most of them fully vaccinated, one player was recovered and one player unvaccinated. The football club was perplexed and could not really explain the outbreak. 

The public discussion was conducted in a manner that the unvaccinated player was suspected as the source for viral spread. But he had the lowest viral load of all players; the viral RNA was barely detectable in his two samples suggesting that other players are much more likely to be the source of the outbreak (15).

Recently, an outbreak occurred in Münster, Germany, among 380 people who were either fully vaccinated or recovered from Covid-19. They attended a club resulting in at least 85 new Covid-19 cases (16).

Recent data on the number of new Covid-19 cases in various US counties with different vaccination levels indicate that there is no discernible relationship between the percentage of population fully vaccinated and new Covid-19 cases. Of the top five counties that have the highest percentage of population fully vaccinated (99.9–84.3%), the US Centres for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) identifies four of them as “high” transmission counties (17).

In Israel a nosocomial outbreak of Covid-19 was reported involving 16 healthcare workers, 23 exposed patients and two family members. The source was a fully vaccinated patient who was diagnosed to have Covid-19. Under all exposed individuals (151 healthcare workers and 97 patients) the vaccination rate was 96.2%. Fourteen fully vaccinated patients became severely ill or died, the two unvaccinated patients developed mild disease (18).

Fully vaccinated persons with a Covid-19 infection were still able to excrete infectious SARS-CoV-2 six to seven days after the onset of symptoms in half of the cases (19). Even transmission from fully vaccinated Covid-19-infected persons has been described (20). Finally, the CDC reported that the delta variant appears to produce the same high levels of virus in both unvaccinated and vaccinated individuals (21).

Vaccinated people may even accelerate the spread of SARS-CoV-2

One benefit of vaccination is that severe courses of Covid-19 become less likely and thus the symptoms of infection are milder in vaccinated individuals. Thus, some vaccinated patients will have only mild symptoms who would have experienced severe symptoms without vaccination. Other vaccinated patients will have no symptoms who would have experienced only mild symptoms without vaccination. 

Vaccinated people usually behave in a more risk-taking way, they have more contacts, go to concerts and parties more often. They are no longer tested in Germany and are not quarantined. It is a carte blanche for an almost normal social life. If they become infected, they often have no or only mild symptoms and thus do not recognize their infection or recognize it too late. As a result, the expected wave among the vaccinated would hardly be visible. It is to be feared that infections in Germany will spill over from there to the currently 3.4 million unvaccinated people over 60 (22).

The phase 3 trial with AZD 1222 showed already that the proportion of asymptomatic Covid-19 cases is similar among both the vaccinated and unvaccinated study participants (1.0% versus 1.0%) underlining the relevance of asymptomatic vaccinated individuals as a potential source for transmission (7). The increasing proportion of breakthrough infection in countries with a high vaccination level shows in addition that the virus multiplies in both the vaccinated and unvaccinated.

The vaccinated may contribute to variants

In the world of bacteria, Darwin’s principle of the survival of the fittest is known that any selection pressure caused by antibiotics and biocidal agents enhances tolerance, finally resulting in a cellular adaptive response which enables the cell to survive in a rather hostile environment (23). If this principle is transferred to viruses, it may well be that the vaccinated with a partial immunity for Covid-19 could have better contributed to the development of variants that can at least partially escape human immune responses (24). 

Given the emergence of immunity-evading variants even before vaccines were broadly deployed, it is hard to implicate vaccines or vaccine deployment strategies as the major drivers of immune evasion (24). That is why it seems to be possible or even likely that the infected vaccinated can also be a pool for variants and thereby continue to contribute to the pandemic.

Continue reading at:
Discerning the Mystery is a website dedicated to awakening and educating the people to their true potential of mental, spiritual, emotional, and physical growth. It can be difficult work, but if just one person benefits from these efforts, it is entirely worth it. 

If you enjoy what you read here, please give the post a like and share on social media. Also, if you enjoyed this article, please consider leaving a donation.

Feel free to send us an email and tell us what you think. If you have any suggestions or subjects you would like to see discussed, please let us know.

Thank you for your support.

No comments:

Post a Comment