Thursday, August 16, 2018

THE REAL RUSSIA STORY - Port Canaveral 'Project Pelican' - The Shocking Truth behind Uranium 1


The truth about the possible Russian involvement in the 2016 election appears to be coming forward. This information does not appear to comprise the story which the MSM has consistently promoted as news. Rather, these revelations include excessive amounts of evidence suggesting that previous administrations were involved in treasonous interactions with Russian interests.


Many of us may remember the disclosure of the Uranium 1 scandal and how these revelations helped to paint a new picture for the corporate media's apparent obsession with the notion of Russian aggression. However, due to the complete lack of evidence (even after the investigation had been ongoing for two years straight), combined with the fact that the FBI and the Secret Service have been caught deliberately attempting to sabotage the presidential seat, it seems very likely that the continued promotion of Russian rhetoric may merely be more attempts of a compromised media and corrupt government agencies to undermine and sabotage an American president.

Related links - FBI Official: FBI Agents Threatened Physical Harm to President Trump In Missing FBI Texts and Other “Frightening” Communications

It may be difficult for some to grasp the very strong likelihood that the entire anti-Russian meme was nothing more than a propaganda campaign designed to distract the American people. However, due to the massive amount of evidence to the fact, the notion appears to be highly valid.

It is a natural tactic of professional propagandists to accuse one's enemy of that which they are guilty of. This was the tactic of infamous Nazi media head, Joseph Goebbels, and it appears this tactic is commonly used against modern-day Americans. If we want to know the true origin of propaganda, all we need is to acknowledge who or what the target is and who benefits from such manipulation.

In the case of the Russian collusion meme—a narrative which has been officially dismissed as invalid, and yet is still being obsessed over by a novelty media—this meme appears to be designed to distract from a real scandal of Russian collusion.

This real scandal actually involved the deliberate exporting of American-mined uranium to covert Russian interests. The smuggling operation took place under the guise of foreign trade and was not at all covered by any corporate media outlet. According to research, the reason behind it appears to be self-explanatory. However, due to our need for a more complete revelation, here is the website, Center for Security Policy, with the details.

* * * * *

Source: Center for Security Policy

Published: March 2, 2018

By: Mary Fanning and Alan Jones

Gulftainer is connected to the Uranium One deal.

Gulftainer is the Iraqi Jafar family’s UAE-based ports company that is tightly connected to Russia and Saddam Hussein’s nuclear weapons programs.

In 2014 the Obama administration awarded Gulftainer a 35-year lease to Florida’s Port Canaveral cargo container terminal in a secret deal code-named “Project Pelican.”


Jafars partner with Russia’s Inter RAO UES, a subsidiary of Rosatom, majority owner of Uranium One

In 2011, Gulftainer affiliate Crescent Investments partnered via a Strategic Cooperation Agreement with Russia’s state-owned power station operator and electricity import-export monopoly Inter RAO UES.

At that time, Inter RAO UES was a subsidiary of Russia’s Rosatom State Atomic Energy Corporation. Rosatom is the Russian company that purchased Uranium One.

Related links - Disclosure of CIA/Islamic State Collusion - Ben Rhodes Admits Obama Armed Jihadists in Syria in 'Bombshell Interview'

The Russian government’s military industrial complex, petroleum industry, electrical power grid, nuclear energy sector, and nuclear weapons complex, are all components of a giant web of state-controlled enterprises. Their business structures may routinely shift like the sand dunes in a desert, but these key sectors always remain under the control of Vladimir Putin and the Kremlin.

Rosatom controls Russia’s sprawling nuclear weapons production complex.

Rosatom purchased Canadian mining company Uranium One in a deal that transferred control of one-fifth of U.S. uranium reserves, a strategic national security commodity critical to U.S. nuclear defense, into the hands of Russia and Vladimir Putin.

Inter RAO UES is chaired by Igor Sechin who at the time of the Crescent Investment deal was Russia’s Deputy Prime Minister and the head of Russia’s petroleum giant Rosneft.

Rosneft is a Russian state-owned enterprise in business with Crescent Petroleum, another Gulftainer affiliate.

Forbes reported in January 2018 that Sechin, known as “the Darth Vader of Russia, is “more powerful than Russian prime minister Dmitry Medvedev,” “more powerful than Vladimir Putin” and “feared more than Putin.”


Management frequently moves among Rosatom, Inter RAO UES, and Uranium One

The management of Inter RAO UES, Uranium One, and Uranium One’s majority owner Rosatom, has been a revolving door. Management moves among these three Russian companies freely and frequently.


Boris Kovalchuk is Chairman of the Management Board, Inter RAO. “In 2009, he (Kovalchuk) was Deputy Director General for Development of the State Atomic Energy Corporation Rosatom” according to Inter RAO’s 2015 Annual Report. Rosatom’s acquisition of Uranium One was well underway in 2009.

Mikhail Kontserev, Senior Vice President of Uranium One Group, “served as CEO of the joint venture of ROSATOM and INTER RAO – INTER RAO UES Energy Efficiency Center LLC” according to his biography featured on Uranium One’s official website.


The Iraqi Jafar Family’s History With WMD

The Crescent Group Chairman and Gulftainer co-owner Hamid Jafar and his brother and business partner, rogue Iraqi nuclear physicist Dr. Jafar Dhia Jafar, were both deeply involved in Saddam Hussein’s massive top-secret uranium enrichment and nuclear weapons programs.

The Pentagon placed Dr. Jafar on CENTCOM’s “Blacklist” in 2003, designated Jafar as a senior Saddam regime official enemy combatant who was wanted for capture and could be legitimately targeted by U.S. and coalition military forces.

To the surprise of UN weapons inspector David Kay, Dr. Jafar was able to draw detailed diagrams from memory showing exactly how to build a nuclear weapon.

Related links - "Explosive", "Shocking" And "Alarming" FISA Memo Set To Rock DC, "End Mueller Investigation"

Dr. Jafar stated “You can bomb our buildings. You can destroy our technology. But you cannot take it out of our heads. We now have the capability.”

Dr. Jafar is also known for his miniaturized nuclear weapon, the Iraqi “Beach Ball.”

North Korea’s Kim Jong Un was seen in 2017 on North Korean television with a what appeared to be a miniaturized nuclear weapon strikingly similar to Dr. Jafar’s “Beach Ball.” Dr. Jafar and Kim Jong Un’s father’s regime worked in concert for a delivery system for a North Korean ballistic missile production line to be built in Iraq.

Dr. Jafar’s brother, Crescent Group Chairman Hamid Jafar, also came under scrutiny. Hamid Jafar was investigated by multiple Congressional committees and the U.S. Treasury Department for operating Crescent Petroleum as a Saddam front company in a WMD funding scheme known as “Oil-For-Superweapons.”

The Obama administration awarded the Jafar family’s Gulftainer the keys to Port Canaveral’s cargo container terminal despite the fact that Soviet-trained nuclear physicist Dr. Jafar, an Electromagnetic Isotope Separation (EMIS) uranium enrichment expert, oversaw a clandestine Iraqi program to enrich uranium to weapons-grade military specifications in pursuit of Saddam’s “Arab Bomb.”

Dr. Jafar is the CEO of Crescent Group subsidiary Uruk Power, which builds power stations.

Dr. Jafar repurposed Iraqi power stations to clandestinely send electricity to his secret EMIS uranium enrichment WMD sites in support of Jafar’s and Saddam’s “Arab Bomb” program.

Dr. Jafar has taken the lead in Crescent’s partnership with Inter RAO, working with the Russians on new power plant projects in the Middle East. According to Dr. Jafar’s nephew Badr Jafar:

“Looking at opportunities within Russia itself, the other main subsidiary of the Crescent Group, Crescent Enterprises, owns a company called Gulftainer, which today is the largest privately owned port operator in the world in terms of operated volumes. Gulftainer is looking to expand its geographic footprint by investing in Russia’s underdeveloped Ports and Logistics sector, specifically the management of container terminals, logistics partnerships, and inland depots. Another one of Crescent Enterprises’ subsidiaries, URUK Power, is active in the power sector and is looking at power opportunities alongside Inter RAO UES, one of Russia’s largest energy companies.” – Badr Jafar, CEO of Crescent Enterprises and President of Crescent Petroleum – Leaders Magazine interview – October 4, 2013


Port Canaveral is the nexus of critical military and space infrastructure

Port Canaveral is critical military infrastructure and a major U.S. port integral to U.S. national defense and space security.

Port Canaveral is adjacent to NASA’s Kennedy Space Center and Canaveral Air Force Station, where American spy satellites are launched.

Gulftainer’s Port Canaveral cargo container terminal sits a few hundred yards from a U.S. Navy Trident nuclear submarine base.


Russia’s Club-K Container Cruise Missile Launch System – A game changer

As we previously reported, the Jafar’s Gulftainer has entered into a joint venture with Russia’s state-owned weapons manufacturer Rostec. Rostec exports Russia’s Trojan Horse Club-K cargo container cruise missile launch system through Rostec’s wholly-owned subsidiary Rosoboronexport.


The Club-K is designed to look identical to standard cargo containers. The Club-K allows Russia and her rogue regime allies stealth access to the United States. The Club-K bypasses early-warning systems by launching Russian Kalibr cruise missiles armed with nuclear, EMP, or conventional warheads from cargo ships off U.S. shores or from trains, trucks, and riverine boats inside every hamlet in America.

Related links - Was Trump Missile Attack Part of Secret Plan to End Syria Conflict & Prevent War with Iran? - Exopolitics

These Russian cruise missiles are capable of flying at supersonic speeds beneath U.S. early-warning radar systems from Trojan Horse “cargo containers,” simultaneously travelling toward multiple cities or other satellite-guided coordinates across the United States.

The Jafars entered into their joint venture with Rostec in 2010.

Why was this dire threat ignored by the Obama administration officials who helped Gulftainer secure a lease at Port Canaveral and bypass the required National Security Threat Analysis?


No CFIUS review for “Project Pelican” Gulftainer deal

The Obama administration declined to subject the “Project Pelican” Gulftainer Port Canaveral deal to the mandated Committee on Foreign Investment in the United States (CFIUS) National Security Threat Analysis.

That National Security Threat Analysis, which includes input from sixteen U.S. intelligence agencies, was bypassed by the Obama administration.

That review would have revealed that the Jafars were at the center of Saddam Hussein’s uranium enrichment and nuclear weapons programs.

The mandated CFIUS review would have also revealed that the Jafars had partnered with Russian state-owned companies behind the Uranium One deal.

That CFIUS review would also have shown that the Jafars are inextricably intertwined with the Russian companies behind the production of Russian nuclear weapons, and are behind the export of the Club-K container cruise missile launch system – all Russian military-industrial weapons programs that could be used in a surprise attack against America using cruise missiles launched from “cargo containers.”


Clintons tied to Gulftainer “Project Pelican” deal and to Uranium One deal

Bill and Hillary Clinton and the Clinton Foundation are tied to both Gulftainer’s “Project Pelican” deal and to the Uranium One deal.

Breitbart reported on October 17, 2017:

“Hillary Clinton’s State Department was one of eight agencies to review and sign off on the sale of U.S. uranium to Russia. However, the then-Secretary of State Clinton was the only agency head whose family foundation received $145 million in donations from multiple people connected to the uranium deal, as reported by the New York Times.”

As previously reported, Bill Clinton co-chairs the Dubai-based Business Backs Education program alongside Crescent Petroleum CEO Majid Jafar. Business Backs Education is funded by the Varkey GEMS Foundation.


According to the Varkey Foundation website:

“The Varkey GEMS Foundation has helped to facilitate more than 2,300 commitments through the Clinton Global Initiative to date. Upon funding and implementation, these commitments will have a total value of over $70 billion.”


Gates Foundation, World Bank hire auditor, ask The Abraaj Group: Where is our money?

Hamid Jafar is founding shareholder of Pakistani private equity firm The Abraaj Group.

The Wall Street Journal reported on February 2, 2018 that The Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation, The World Bank International FInance Corporation (IFC), and two other institutional investors asked The Abraaj Group for bank statements to determine what happened to hundreds of millions of dollars sent to Abraaj’s $1 billion health care fund that were earmarked for construction of hospitals and medical clinics in Pakistan, India, Nigeria, and Kenya. After The Abraaj Group refused to turn over bank statements, the investors retained auditing firm Ankura Consulting Group to conduct a forensic trace on the money.

Related links - Operation Fast and Furious - FBI Caught Delivering High-Powered Weapons to Criminal Organizations

Reuters UK reports that “Mr. (Hamid) Jafar is Chairman of Gulftainer Ltd, Founding Shareholder of Abraaj Capital, and URUK Group.”

Gulftainer is a unit of Crescent Enterprises, a subsidiary of the Jafars’ Crescent Group. The CEO of Crescent Enterprises is Badr Jafar. Badr Jafar is also a member of The Abraaj Group Board of Directors in addition to serving as the Chairman of the Gulftainer Executive Board.

The Crescent Enterprises 2013 Annual Report states:

“As a Founding Shareholder and Limited Partner of Abraaj, Crescent Enterprises monitors the performance of all invested funds, and takes a keen interest in the strategic rationale employed by Abraaj on select investment decisions, including review of coinvestment opportunities whenever possible. Crescent Enterprises also provides strategic guidance by means of representation on Abraaj’s Board of Directors.”

Wahid Hamid, a former Pakistani foreign student who attended Occidental College with Barack Obama, and remains very close to the former president, is a Managing Partner of The Abraaj Group. Wahid Hamid travelled with Barack Obama during his mysterious 1981 trip to Pakistan.


As previously reported in 2016 by The American Report and 1776 Channel:

“Weeks before co-sponsoring the 2012 Clinton Global Initiative meeting, The Abraaj Group was awarded the first of hundreds of millions of dollars in loans and investment management contracts through the State Department’s Overseas Private Investment Corporation (OPIC), a federal agency overseen by Secretary of State Hillary Clinton.”

The Washington Free Beacon reported in 2016 that The Abraaj Group donated between $500,000 and $1 million to the Clinton Foundation around the same time the private equity firm received OPIC funds management contracts and loans through the State Department.

The Washington Free Beacon also reported:

“Authorities in Sindh province (Pakistan) have accused a prominent government official of providing illegal favors to K-Electric, a power company owned and managed by the Abraaj Group since 2009.

Former Pakistani oil minister Dr. Asim Hussain was arrested last year amid allegations that he helped harbor terrorists in a string of hospitals he owned and doled out illegal contracts to companies, including K-Electric. Both Hussain and K-Electric have denied the allegations.”


Read more at: CenterForSecurityPolicy.org

* * * * *

The Implications

Let's consider the seriousness of this alleged conspiracy. Consider the implications and detail of underhanded plotting that went into this attempt to place advanced Russian nukes into U.S. ports. A ballistic missile system designed to look exactly like a cargo container is not typically something U.S. intelligence allows to sit in American harbors.

While the corporate media focused on cheap drama, fear, and the exploits of a porn star, the reality that the country was almost attacked in unimaginable ways was being ignored.

It appears as though the Obama administration planned to somehow team up with Russian interests possibly for a false flag which far surpassed the magnitude of the September 11th attacks. If this intel is true regarding the intent of both American and Russian operatives, this is a serious accusation.

The scheme seems eerily similar to the exact same false flag of 9/11, according to research. Only this time, it appears as though the potential damage would not only rest within one city or on a couple of city blocks. If this report represents a real attempt of the Obama administration to 9/11 the entire country, this may be the revelation of the century.

We might remember the story which followed the attacks of September 11, 2001. Some of the more-easily forgotten news headlines were on the subject of how the country of Iraq was given legal immunity from lawsuits for the suffering and death following the devastation of the attacks. This was a strange legal maneuver enacted by the presidential administration at the time, and helped to reveal the gross flaws within the mainstream reports on the attacks.

Related links - 'Banned' 9/11 Newscast Repeatedly Points Out What They Don’t Want Us to Hear; Attacks Show the True Nature of Many Alleged False Flags

Many researchers and investigators have concluded that the 9/11 attacks were not executed by terrorists with box-cutters, but by a number of different interests. The Bush administration (Dick Cheney more specifically), Israel, and Saudi Arabia were all believed to have participated in orchestrating the September 11 attacks. It is not surprising that none of these interests have been held to account for these allegations, as the established media and judicial system were acting to conceal the entire collusion, according to research.

We might also find it interesting that these interests were all respected and even praised while all of these heinous actions were taking place behind the scenes. Kim Jong-un was still behaving as violently as ever, Saudi Arabian was a ticking time-bomb, and Russia was busily accepting destructive plans from the then-presidential administration. Even still, the corporate media never raised a single alarm about the greatest of these problems.

To this day, the MSM has still not addressed the overt and violent criminality of past administrations. Instead, these questionable interests have chosen to demonize the first president to bring these past governmental ills to light.

According to numerous sources, there are those within the MSM who have actually listened to officials who have confirmed that there was no foul play needed in order to elect the current president. However, this is only the half of the situation.

In truth, if the corporate media really cared about Russian collusion, this report from CSP would not be the first time so many people would be hearing about this story. If the corporate media truly cared about preventing Russian collusion, they would report it whenever it took place and not simply when the commonly used scapegoat/distraction is suspected of it.


Western MSM — The Real Threat

Most Americans know the name Vladimir Putin largely from the apparent smearing and demonization rhetoric constantly streaming from the corporate media. Granted, this prime minister will naturally have his share of problems. However, it seems strange that the Western media was attempting to concentrate so heavily upon how supposedly evil this prime minister is at every turn.

In the West, Putin has been smeared for a long while as being the worst threat that America has ever faced. This Cold-War style rhetoric may seem confusing to many MSM audience members. To add, most Americans may not be aware of the financial powers in Russia which pose an actual threat.

There are numerous other influential figures in Russia that are more highly feared by other nations than Putin ever was, yet Western media rarely ever speaks of them.

Igor Sechin, for example, is known as the Darth Vader of Russia, and yet his reputation is hardly a subject of interest for the sensationalist Western MSM. Sechin has become notorious for his role of CEO of the Russian company, Rosneft and has contributed to the ruining of several billionaires. By comparison, we might consider Sechin's role as similar to that of George Soros, who has become notorious for manipulated countries and governments to his own advantage.

Related links - Billionaire Globalist Soros Exposed as Hidden Hand Behind Trump Protests, Provoking US "Color Revolution" - Video, Links, and Commentary

Yet despite the financially manipulative escapades of Igor Sechin, the Western media never even bothers to mention him. This seems to reveal the fact that Western MSM sources do not actually care about protecting Western elections or anything else they claim to care about.

By all appearances, it only seems that these media sources are only interested in pushing the idea of a global nuclear holocaust while, ironically, they failed to report the fact that one was almost successfully orchestrated by the Obama administration, according to reports.

Even after the U.S. president had a cordial exchange in connection with the American/Russian summit, the corporate media has still searched for any and every reason to smear the entire event along with everything else the U.S. president participates in. All the while, the corporate media completely ignores what could be the greatest conspiracy of the last two centuries—a 9/11 event that could have possibly ended the world. Fortunately, such disasters will not be allowed to happen, according to sources.


Propaganda, Confessions, and Censorship

Many of us might remember the journalistic contributions of the late, Dr. Udo Ulfkotte. Dr. Ulfkotte was a well-known journalist in Europe and who turned whistleblower to expose the CIA-based manipulation which was taking place in Europe and other regions.

Ulfkotte was one of the only journalists that was brave enough to come forward with this information. Unfortunately, he mysteriously died of a heart attack not long after his disclosure efforts. Many suspected that he was assassinated via psycho-electric weaponrya technology disclosed by the Washington State Fusion Center which has the potential to negatively affect a target's internal anatomy from great distances. However, the real answers are not available as of yet.

Below is one of several testimonials in which Dr. Ulfkotte revealed the hidden story of journalistic manipulation by the CIA.



Recent Revelations

It was suggested by several mainstream outlets that the Russian collusion meme was not at all caused by anything that President Trump did, but instead, the collusion took place within the Democratic Party and the Clinton camp. This was actually confirmed several months ago by investigations into former democratic campaign manager and suspected pedophile, John Podesta's, leaked emails.

Related links - COLD HARD RUBLES - Podesta Group Found to be Working for Pro-Russian Ukrainian Political Party, Emails Reveal

Below is an excerpt from the disclosure suggesting that Hillary Clinton and the democratic officials frivolously did business with Russian interests and deliberately pinned the entire escapade on a legitimately elected president.

The media have spun a tale of Trump selling his soul to the Russians for campaign dirt to use against Hillary, beginning with the now-infamous Trump Tower meeting.

But "a growing body of evidence ... indicates that the meeting may have been a setup — part of a broad effort to tarnish the Trump campaign involving Hillary Clinton operatives employed by Kremlin-linked figures and Department of Justice officials," wrote Smith.

Smith painstakingly weaves together the evidence that's already out there but has been largely ignored by the mainstream media, which have become so seized with Trump-hatred that their reporting even on routine matters can no longer be trusted.

But he adds in more evidence that the Justice Department only recently handed over to Congress. And It's damning.

Memos, emails and texts now in Congress' possession show that the Justice Department and the FBI worked together both before and after the election with Fusion GPS and their main link to the scandal, former British spy and longtime FBI informant Chris Steele.

As a former British spook in Moscow, Steele had extensive ties to Russia. That's why he was picked as the primary researcher to compile the "unverified and salacious" Trump dossier, as former FBI Director James Comey once described it.

Steele's dossier, for which Fusion reportedly received $1 million, was largely based on interviews with Russian officials. And who paid that $1 million? As we and others have reported, it was Hillary Clinton's campaign and the Democratic National Committee, then under Hillary's control.

The media knew all this, of course, but largely ignored it.

The great irony here is that, after more than two years of investigating, the only real evidence of collusion with Russians at all points to Hillary Clinton. It was she who hired Steele to dig up dirt on Trump using Russian sources.

But now, it turns out, it goes even deeper than that.

https://www.investors.com/politics/editorials/russian-collusion-hillary-clinton/

Though this excerpt only represents two mainstream sources acknowledging this information, the disclosure is still suggested. The postings by Investors.com and Yahoo seem to show the fact that there is no longer a blanket of censorship covering the entirety of the subject of Democratic corruption (though both parties are said to be corrupt in their own specific ways).


Interesting References

Some might look at the name of Project Pelican and be reminded of the book by author, John Grisham, and the movie dramatizationThe Pelican Brief. This story is about a duo of lawyers who work on different cases together.


One of these lawyers—Darby Shaw—is actually still a law student in the story, but as part of an exercise, she writes up a case scenario about an off-shore conspiracy which receives much more attention than any typical assignment. The fictional conspiracy involves several oil companies and political interests that devise a way to profit off of oil-drilling while destroying wetlands, all while hiding their actions through a number of corporate smokescreens. The assignment was supposed to be a mere exercise, but the story Darby writes turns out to be true (in the story).

The conspiracy is somewhat tame in comparison to the disclosures of actual conspiracy in more recent times. However, the name of the novel and the movie seem particularly suggestive of Project Pelican which involved real estate in the same area of the country. The relationship seems to suggest some level of soft disclosure. However, this is only speculation.

Whether or not there is any correlation between the novel and the actual deals made during Project Pelican, it seems that we have much more to uncover on the subject of the atrocious acts by former administrations.
Other Related Topics...


Benjamin Fulford - Revolution May Start in France as Crazy Zionists Try Yet Again to Start WW3 - Full Report

Ex-FBI Assistant Director Says Upcoming Inspector General Report Is "Pure TNT" - Zero Hedge
US Senate Calls on Julian Assange to Testify before U.S. Intelligence Committee on Russia Investigation

THE MEMO Has Been Released - The Details and Denotations - Videos, Links, and Commentary

IRS Caught Targeting of Conservative Groups - Past Disclosures and Present-Day Significance

BIG CHANGES IN FLORIDA - Sheriff Scott Israel to be Removed from Office; Removal Comes in Tandem with Retirement of Thirteen Broward County Judges

REVEALED: Sheriff Joe Arpaio Releases New Information on President Obama's True Identity - Video and Analysis

The 'Storm' Has Arrived - Executive Order Blocking the Property of Persons Involved in Serious Human Rights Abuse or Corruption - Commentary, Video, and Links Included

Who Controls the World? - The True Story behind Money and Media Manipulation with TED X - Video, Links and Extended Commentary

Benjamin Fulford - Will the Jews Finally be Freed from Khazarian Mafia Slavery as Israel is Liberated? - Partial Update for July 16, 2018







Discerning the Mystery is a website dedicated to awakening and educating the people to their true potential of mental, spiritual, emotional, and physical growth. It can be difficult work, but if just one person benefits from these efforts, it is entirely worth it. 

If you enjoy what you read here, please give the post a like and share on social media. Also, if you enjoyed this article, please consider leaving a donation.

Feel free to send us an email and tell us what you think. If you have any suggestions or subjects you would like to see discussed, please let us know.


Thank you for your support.




No comments:

Post a Comment